By Joan Mccarthy
McCarthy starts with Dennett’s naturalist objectivist account of the narrative self. in particular, she considers Dennett’s use of the language of laptop programming and his model of the self as one of those downloadable software program package deal, an invaluable theoretical fiction but one who isn't genuine in any scientifically appropriate feel. She poses a few objections to his naturalist method of the matter of human selfhood.
Turning to Ricoeur, she assesses his phenomenological-hermeneutic account of the self as a culturally mediated narrative cohesion. In evaluating Ricoeur’s suggestion of self as an embodied personality (as in a play or novel) woven from the various plots of a unmarried lifestyles to Dennett’s neuroscientific version, McCarthy eventually reveals Ricoeur’s procedure extra finished. the most important benefit of Ricoeur’s interpretation is that it focuses, no longer on issues, yet on relationships among primarily human actions, akin to constructing long term tasks or making delivers. She criticizes Dennett’s over the top objectivism as being too slim to account for the richness and many-faceted points of human life.
Finally she makes hyperlinks with different modern students who're deploying theories of narrative selfhood so one can handle questions of ethical business enterprise in a brand new mild. This new method of moral concerns, narrative ethics, is at present the topic of a lot debate in bioethical literature.
Read or Download Dennett and Ricoeur on the Narrative Self (Contemporary Studies in Philosophy and the Human Sciences) PDF
Best philosophy criticism books
Ludwig Wittgenstein (1889-1951) has exerted a extra strong impact on modern philosophy than the other twentieth-century philosopher. yet what's the nature of this effect and why has it proved so enduring? In Wittgenstein's Lasting importance, twelve modern philosophers discover the problems surrounding Wittgenstein's significance and relevance to trendy notion.
The second one variation Contradictory interpretations were utilized to history-making occasions that resulted in the tip of the chilly battle: Václav Havel, utilizing Kierkegaardian phrases, known as the loss of life of totalitarianism in East-Central Europe an “existential revolution” (i. e. an awakening of human accountability, spirit, and reason), whereas others hailed it as a victory for the “New global Order.
Donald Capps and John Capps's James and Dewey on trust and event juxtaposes the most important writings of 2 philosophical superstars. As fathers of Pragmatism, America's distinct contribution to international philosophy, their paintings has been vastly influential, and continues to be necessary to any figuring out of yank highbrow background.
In recent times curiosity within the considered Kierkegaard has grown dramatically, and with it the physique of secondary literature has accelerated so fast that it has develop into most unlikely for even the main conscientious student to maintain velocity. the matter of the explosion of secondary literature is made extra acute via the truth that a lot of what's written approximately Kierkegaard seems in languages that almost all Kierkegaard students don't know.
- Re-Presenting the Good Society (Studies in Contemporary German Social Thought)
- De Lingua Belief (MIT Press)
- Informal Philosophy
- Postmodern Rationality, Social Criticism, and Religion (Paragon Issues in Philosophy)
- The Language of Criticism (Routledge Revivals)
- Kristeva Reframed: Interpreting Key Thinkers for the Arts (Contemporary Thinkers Reframed)
Extra info for Dennett and Ricoeur on the Narrative Self (Contemporary Studies in Philosophy and the Human Sciences)
Dennett and Ricoeur on the Narrative Self (Contemporary Studies in Philosophy and the Human Sciences) by Joan Mccarthy